Did Jesus Call the Canaanite Woman a Dog?

Jesus and the Canaanite woman

In Matthew 15:26-28, there is a story of a Canaanite woman who approaches Jesus and pleads with him to heal her daughter. Jesus initially seems to ignore her and speaks to his disciples about how he is only sent to heal the lost sheep of Israel. The woman, however, persists and says, "Even the dogs eat the crumbs that fall from their master's table." Jesus responds by praising her faith and healing her daughter.

Some interpret Jesus' initial statement as calling the woman a dog, and therefore as an example of racism or discrimination. However, this interpretation is not necessarily the only one. In the context of the story, Jesus is emphasizing his mission to the Israelites and the woman's persistence in approaching him despite this. He does not actually refer to her as a dog, but rather she uses the metaphor herself to express her willingness to accept even the smallest blessing from him.

Furthermore, the term "dogs" in the ancient world did not have the same negative connotation as it does today. In the Bible, "dogs" were often used as a metaphor for Gentiles, or non-Israelites, and did not necessarily carry a negative connotation. In this context, the woman's use of the term "dogs" is not a derogatory statement about herself, but rather a recognition of her status as a Gentile.

Additionally, Jesus' response to the woman is one of praise and admiration for her faith. He commends her for her persistence and acknowledges that her faith is greater than that of the Israelites he has been sent to heal. In this way, the story is not an example of discrimination, but rather an illustration of the universality of Jesus' message and the inclusivity of his mission.

It's also important to note that the story can also be understood in light of the concept of the "outsider" or "other" in Jewish culture. The woman is not just a gentile, but a Canaanite which would have been seen as the most despised group among Jews. Jesus' response to her can be seen as a challenge to the societal norms of the time and a message of inclusion of those who have been marginalized.

In conclusion, the story of the Canaanite woman in Matthew 15:26-28 does not necessarily depict Jesus as calling her a dog. The woman's use of the metaphor "dogs" does not have a negative connotation and Jesus' response to her is one of praise for her faith. The story can be seen as an illustration of the universality of Jesus' message and the inclusivity of his mission. It also challenges the societal norms of the time and a message of inclusion of those who have been marginalized.

Previous
Next Post »